From 8b1341528e8028d5569240f60e7a0521388b22a3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Guilhem Moulin <guilhem.moulin@fripost.org>
Date: Mon, 28 Jan 2013 02:30:30 +0100
Subject: List commands are now created by the user him/herself.

---
 ldap/acl.ldif         |  50 +++++----
 ldap/populate.ldif    |  20 ++++
 ldap/test-user-acl.sh | 281 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++----
 3 files changed, 312 insertions(+), 39 deletions(-)

(limited to 'ldap')

diff --git a/ldap/acl.ldif b/ldap/acl.ldif
index 7b19d5f..5cc0ef0 100644
--- a/ldap/acl.ldif
+++ b/ldap/acl.ldif
@@ -84,9 +84,9 @@ olcAccess: to dn.regex="^fvd=[^,]+,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev$"
     by dnattr=fripostOwner =z break
     by * =0 break
 #
-# The list creation service can delete the 'pending' status on lists.
+# The list creation service can delete the 'pending' status on lists and list commands.
 olcAccess: to dn.regex="^fvl=[^,]+,fvd=[^,]+,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev$"
-        filter=(&(objectClass=FripostVirtualList)(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry))
+        filter=(&(|(objectClass=FripostVirtualList)(objectClass=FripostVirtualListCommand))(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry))
         attrs=objectClass val=FripostPendingEntry
     by dn.exact="cn=CreateList,ou=services,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev" =z break
     by * +0 break
@@ -97,7 +97,7 @@ olcAccess: to dn.subtree="ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev"
     by * +rscd
 #
 # The pending token is not public, but domain owner and postmasters can check their and
-# delete it (upon success, but it's done on the library side).
+# delete it (if the token matches, but the check is done on the library side).
 olcAccess: to dn.regex="^fvd=[^,]+,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev$"
         filter=(&(objectClass=FripostVirtualDomain)(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry))
         attrs=fripostPendingToken
@@ -105,9 +105,9 @@ olcAccess: to dn.regex="^fvd=[^,]+,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev$"
     by dnattr=fripostOwner =zcd break
     by * +0 break
 #
-# The list creation service can delete the 'pending' status on lists.
+# The list creation service can delete the 'pending' status on lists and list commands.
 olcAccess: to dn.regex="^fvl=[^,]+,fvd=[^,]+,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev$"
-        filter=(&(objectClass=FripostVirtualList)(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry))
+        filter=(&(|(objectClass=FripostVirtualList)(objectClass=FripostVirtualListCommand))(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry))
         attrs=fripostPendingToken
     by dn.exact="cn=CreateList,ou=services,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev" +z
     by * +0
@@ -119,14 +119,6 @@ olcAccess: to dn.children="ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev"
     by dn.exact="cn=DeletePendingEntries,ou=services,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev" =zrd break
     by * =0 break
 #
-# Only the list creation service may add list commands. (It seems unsafe since it can create
-# arbitrary commands, but as other services it run in safe environments only.)
-# (Listcommands are not concerned by the cleaning service.)
-olcAccess: to dn.regex="^fvl=[^,]+-[^,-]+,fvd=[^,]+,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev$"
-        filter=(objectClass=FripostVirtualListCommand)
-        attrs=entry
-    by dn.exact="cn=CreateList,ou=services,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev" =a
-#
 # One can search search everywhere in the virtual tree.
 olcAccess: to dn.subtree="ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev"
         attrs=entry
@@ -149,7 +141,6 @@ olcAccess: to dn.one="ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev"
         filter=(&(objectClass=FripostVirtualDomain)(!(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)))
         attrs=children
     by dn.children="ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev" =w
-    by dn.exact="cn=CreateList,ou=services,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev" =a
 #
 # The cleaning service needs to know when entries have been created.
 olcAccess: to dn.children="ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev"
@@ -159,6 +150,7 @@ olcAccess: to dn.children="ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev"
 #
 # Users can use these in filters (e.g., to list the entries they have created).
 olcAccess: to dn.children="ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev"
+        filter=(|(objectClass=FripostVirtualDomain)(objectClass=FripostVirtualUser)(objectClass=FripostVirtualAlias)(objectClass=FripostVirtualList))
         attrs=fripostOwner,fripostPostmaster,fripostCanAddAlias,fripostCanAddList
     by dn.children="ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev" =s break
 #
@@ -352,18 +344,38 @@ olcAccess: to dn.regex="^fvl=[^,]+,(fvd=[^,]+,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripos
     by group/FripostVirtualDomain/fripostOwner.expand="$1" =wrscd
     by group/FripostVirtualDomain/fripostPostmaster.expand="$1" =wrscd
 #
-# 1-3. People with "canAddList" access can create lists, but only with a
-# 'pending' status.
-# 4. The list creation service can search and browse the entry.
+# 1. The domain owner can create and delete lists, but only those with a 'pending' status
+# 2. So can the domain postmaster.
+# 3. The list owner can delete pending lists.
+# 4. The entry creator can delete pending lists (needed to be able to rollback).
+# 5. People with "canAddList" access can create lists, but only with a 'pending' status.
+# 6. The list creation service can search and browse the entry.
 olcAccess: to dn.regex="^fvl=[^,]+,(fvd=[^,]+,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev)$"
         filter=(&(objectClass=FripostVirtualList)(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry))
         attrs=entry
-    by group/FripostVirtualDomain/fripostOwner.expand="$1" +a break
-    by group/FripostVirtualDomain/fripostPostmaster.expand="$1" +a break
+    by group/FripostVirtualDomain/fripostOwner.expand="$1" +w break
+    by group/FripostVirtualDomain/fripostPostmaster.expand="$1" +w break
+    by dnattr=fripostOwner +z continue
+    by dnattr=creatorsName +z continue
     by set.exact="this/-1/fripostCanAddList & (user | user/-1)" +a break
     by dn.exact="cn=CreateList,ou=services,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev" +rd
     by * +0 break
 #
+# 1. The domain owner can create and delete list commands, but only those with a 'pending' status
+# 2. So can the domain postmaster.
+# 3. The entry creator can delete pending list commands (needed to be able to rollback).
+# 4. People with "canAddList" access can create list commands, but only with a 'pending' status.
+# 5. The list creation service can search and browse the entry.
+olcAccess: to dn.regex="^fvl=[^,]+,(fvd=[^,]+,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev)$"
+        filter=(&(objectClass=FripostVirtualListCommand)(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry))
+        attrs=entry
+    by group/FripostVirtualDomain/fripostOwner.expand="$1" +w
+    by group/FripostVirtualDomain/fripostPostmaster.expand="$1" +w
+    by dnattr=creatorsName +z continue
+    by set.exact="this/-1/fripostCanAddList & (user | user/-1)" +a
+    by dn.exact="cn=CreateList,ou=services,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev" +rd
+    by * +0
+#
 # 1. The list owners can read the entry.
 # 2. So can the domain's Owner.
 # 3. So can the domain's Postmaster.
diff --git a/ldap/populate.ldif b/ldap/populate.ldif
index edd5d73..73d11fa 100644
--- a/ldap/populate.ldif
+++ b/ldap/populate.ldif
@@ -220,6 +220,26 @@ FripostLocalAlias: list-request#postmastered.org
 objectClass: SimpleSecurityObject
 userPassword: bogus
 
+dn: fvl=list-request,fvd=example2.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev
+objectClass: FripostVirtualListCommand
+objectClass: FripostPendingEntry
+FripostLocalAlias: list-request#example2.org
+
+dn: fvl=list-request,fvd=example3.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev
+objectClass: FripostVirtualListCommand
+objectClass: FripostPendingEntry
+FripostLocalAlias: list-request#example3.org
+
+dn: fvl=list2-request,fvd=postmastered.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev
+objectClass: FripostVirtualListCommand
+objectClass: FripostPendingEntry
+FripostLocalAlias: list2-request#postmastered.org
+
+dn: fvl=list3-request,fvd=owned.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev
+objectClass: FripostVirtualListCommand
+objectClass: FripostPendingEntry
+FripostLocalAlias: list2-request#postmastered.org
+
 dn: fvl=user,fvd=postmastered.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev
 objectClass: FripostVirtualUser
 userPassword: user
diff --git a/ldap/test-user-acl.sh b/ldap/test-user-acl.sh
index cfa577d..5e92a3c 100755
--- a/ldap/test-user-acl.sh
+++ b/ldap/test-user-acl.sh
@@ -421,6 +421,16 @@ usersD ${OPERATTRS} | isOK '=0$' entryUUID
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
 
+msg "Cannot create non-pending entries"
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    for D in ${DOMAINS}; do
+        search -s base -b "${D},${SUFFIX}" "objectClass=FripostPendingEntry" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${D}" entry/add
+    done
+done | isOK 'DENIED$' entry add
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
 # We check the following permissions:
 #  0. Simple user
 #  1. canAddAlias (exact,wildcard)
@@ -894,7 +904,8 @@ echo "Authenticated users, access to list entries"
 # * entry:
 #       =s for all
 #       +a if canAddList, domain owner or domain postmaster
-#       +rd if list owner, domain owner or domain postmaster
+#       +z if creator
+#       +zrd if list owner, domain owner or domain postmaster
 # * children:
 #       =0 for all
 # * objectClass
@@ -942,12 +953,22 @@ done | isOK 'DENIED$' fripostListManager
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
 
-msg "Cannot delete entry or the pending status"
+msg "Cannot remove the pending status"
 for U in ${USERS}; do
     for L in ${LISTS}; do
-        checkACL "${U}" "${L}" objectClass/delete:FripostPendingEntry entry/delete
+        checkACL "${U}" "${L}" objectClass/delete:FripostPendingEntry
     done
-done | isOK 'DENIED$' entry
+done | isOK 'DENIED$' 'objectClass=FripostPendingEntry' delete
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
+msg "Cannot create or delete non-pending entries"
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    for L in ${LISTS}; do
+        search -s base -b "${L},${SUFFIX}" "objectClass=FripostPendingEntry" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${L}" entry/delete entry/add
+    done
+done | isOK 'DENIED$' entry delete
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
 
@@ -1000,7 +1021,7 @@ for U in ${USERS}; do
         DL="$(echo "${L}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
         search -s base -b "${DL},${SUFFIX}" "fripostOwner=${U},${SUFFIX}" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
         search -s base -b "${L},${SUFFIX}" "objectClass=FripostPendingEntry" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
-        checkACL "${U}" "${L}" entry/add
+        checkACL "${U}" "${L}" entry/add entry/delete
     done
 done | isOK 'ALLOWED$' entry add
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
@@ -1015,7 +1036,7 @@ for U in ${USERS}; do
         search -s base -b "${L},${SUFFIX}" "objectClass=FripostPendingEntry" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
         checkACL "${U}" "${L}" entry/add
     done
-done | isOK 'ALLOWED$' entry add
+done | isOK 'ALLOWED$' entry
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
 
@@ -1046,22 +1067,68 @@ done | isOK 'ALLOWED$' entry
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
 
-msg "Do not have >=a access to \"entry\" (unless canAddList)"
+msg "Have >=z access to \"entry\" (if pending list owner)"
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    for L in ${LISTS}; do
+        search -s base -b "${L},${SUFFIX}" "(&(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)(fripostOwner=${U},${SUFFIX}))" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${L}" entry/delete
+    done
+done | isOK 'ALLOWED$' entry
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
+msg "Have >=z access to \"entry\" (if pending list creator)"
+ldapadd -w user2 -xD 'fvl=user2,fvd=fripost.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev' > /dev/null << EOF
+dn: fvl=testlist,fvd=example3.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev
+objectClass: FripostVirtualList
+objectClass: FripostPendingEntry
+FripostLocalAlias: testlist#example3.org
+fripostListManager: mailman
+fripostIsStatusActive: TRUE
+EOF
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    for L in ${LISTS} 'fvl=testlist,fvd=example3.org'; do
+        search -s base -b "${L},${SUFFIX}" "(&(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)(creatorsName=${U},${SUFFIX}))" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${L}" entry/delete
+    done
+done | isOK 'ALLOWED$' entry
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+ldapdelete -w user2 -xD 'fvl=user2,fvd=fripost.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev' \
+           "fvl=testlist,fvd=example3.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev" > /dev/null
+
+
+msg "Do not have +a access to \"entry\" (unless canAddList on pending lists)"
 for U in ${USERS}; do
     DU="$(echo "${U}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
     for L in ${LISTS}; do
         DL="$(echo "${L}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
-        search -s base -b "${DL},${SUFFIX}" "(!(|(fripostCanAddList=${U},${SUFFIX})
-                                                 (fripostCanAddList=${DU},${SUFFIX})
-                                                 (fripostOwner=${U},${SUFFIX})
-                                                 (fripostPostmaster=${U},${SUFFIX})))" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
-        search -s base -b "${L},${SUFFIX}" "(!(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry))" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+        search -s base -b "${DL},${SUFFIX}" "(|(fripostCanAddList=${U},${SUFFIX})
+                                               (fripostCanAddList=${DU},${SUFFIX})
+                                               (fripostOwner=${U},${SUFFIX})
+                                               (fripostPostmaster=${U},${SUFFIX}))" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        search -s base -b "${L},${SUFFIX}" "(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
         checkACL "${U}" "${L}" entry/add
     done
 done | isOK 'DENIED$' entry
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
 
+msg "Do not have +z access to \"entry\" (unless canAddList on pending lists)"
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    DU="$(echo "${U}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
+    for L in ${LISTS}; do
+        DL="$(echo "${L}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
+        search -s base -b "${DL},${SUFFIX}" "(|(fripostOwner=${U},${SUFFIX})
+                                               (fripostPostmaster=${U},${SUFFIX}))" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        search -s base -b "${L},${SUFFIX}" "(fripostOwner=${U},${SUFFIX})" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        search -s base -b "${L},${SUFFIX}" "(creatorsName=${U},${SUFFIX})" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        search -s base -b "${L},${SUFFIX}" "(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${L}" entry/delete
+    done
+done | isOK 'DENIED$' entry
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
 msg "Cannot manage ownership (unless domain owner/domain postmaster)"
 for U in ${USERS}; do
     for L in ${LISTS}; do
@@ -1086,15 +1153,174 @@ for U in ${USERS}; do
 done | isOK 'DENIED$' entry delete
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
-msg "Have =0 access to the list command entries"
+
+###########################################################################
+
+
+echo
+echo "Authenticated users, access to list command entries"
+
+# * entry:
+#       =s for all
+#       +a if canAddList, domain owner or domain postmaster
+#       +zrd if creator, domain owner or domain postmaster
+# * children:
+#       =0 for all
+# * objectClass
+#       =rscd for all
+# * fvl:
+#       =0 forall
+# * localAlias:
+#       =0 for all
+
+
+usersLC () {
+    for U in ${USERS}; do
+        for LC in ${LISTSC}; do
+            checkACL "${U}" "${LC}" "$@"
+        done
+    done
+}
+
+msg "Have >=s access on \"entry\""
+usersLC entry/search | isOK 'ALLOWED$' entry
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+msg "Cannot read entries"
+usersLC entry/read entry/disclose | isOK 'DENIED$' entry read
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
+msg "Have =0 access the \"children\", \"localAlias\" and operational attributes"
+usersLC children fripostLocalAlias ${OPERATTRS} | isOK '=0$' children
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
+msg "Cannot remove the pending status"
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    for LC in ${LISTSC}; do
+        checkACL "${U}" "${LC}" objectClass/delete:FripostPendingEntry
+    done
+done | isOK 'DENIED$' 'objectClass=FripostPendingEntry' delete
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
+msg "Cannot create or delete non-pending entries"
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    for LC in ${LISTSC}; do
+        search -s base -b "${LC},${SUFFIX}" "objectClass=FripostPendingEntry" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${LC}" entry/add entry/delete
+    done
+done | isOK 'DENIED$' entry add
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
+msg "Can create list command (if domain Owner)"
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    for LC in ${LISTSC}; do
+        DL="$(echo "${LC}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
+        search -s base -b "${DL},${SUFFIX}" "fripostOwner=${U},${SUFFIX}" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+        search -s base -b "${LC},${SUFFIX}" "objectClass=FripostPendingEntry" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${LC}" entry/add entry/delete
+    done
+done | isOK 'ALLOWED$' entry add
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
+msg "Can create list command (if domain Postmaster)"
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    for LC in ${LISTSC}; do
+        DL="$(echo "${LC}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
+        search -s base -b "${DL},${SUFFIX}" "fripostPostmaster=${U},${SUFFIX}" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+        search -s base -b "${LC},${SUFFIX}" "objectClass=FripostPendingEntry" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${LC}" entry/add entry/delete
+    done
+done | isOK 'ALLOWED$' entry add
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
+# Needed to create new entries. ("+z" is required to delete, btw.)
+msg "Have >=a access to \"entry\" (if CanAddList, exact)"
 for U in ${USERS}; do
     for LC in ${LISTSC}; do
-        checkACL "${U}" "${LC}"
+        DL="$(echo "${LC}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
+        search -s base -b "${DL},${SUFFIX}" "fripostCanAddList=${U},${SUFFIX}" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+        search -s base -b "${LC},${SUFFIX}" "objectClass=FripostPendingEntry" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${LC}" entry/add
     done
-done | grep -Ev '^objectClass=' | isOK '=0$' entry
+done | isOK 'ALLOWED$' entry
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
 
+# Needed to create new entries. ("+z" is required to delete, btw.)
+msg "Have >=a access to \"entry\" (if CanAddList, wildcard)"
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    DU="$(echo "${U}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
+    for LC in ${LISTSC}; do
+        DL="$(echo "${LC}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
+        search -s base -b "${DL},${SUFFIX}" "fripostCanAddList=${DU},${SUFFIX}" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+        search -s base -b "${LC},${SUFFIX}" "objectClass=FripostPendingEntry" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${LC}" entry/add
+    done
+done | isOK 'ALLOWED$' entry
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
+msg "Have >=z access to \"entry\" (if pending list command creator)"
+ldapadd -w user2 -xD 'fvl=user2,fvd=fripost.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev' > /dev/null << EOF
+dn: fvl=test-request,fvd=example3.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev
+objectClass: FripostVirtualListCommand
+objectClass: FripostPendingEntry
+FripostLocalAlias: test-request#example3.org
+EOF
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    for LC in ${LISTSC} 'fvl=test-request,fvd=example3.org'; do
+        search -s base -b "${LC},${SUFFIX}" "(&(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)(creatorsName=${U},${SUFFIX}))" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${LC}" entry/delete
+    done
+done | isOK 'ALLOWED$' entry
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+ldapdelete -w user2 -xD 'fvl=user2,fvd=fripost.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev' \
+           "fvl=test-request,fvd=example3.org,ou=virtual,o=mailHosting,dc=fripost,dc=dev" > /dev/null
+
+
+msg "Do not have >=a access to \"entry\" (unless canAddList)"
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    DU="$(echo "${U}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
+    for L in ${LISTS}; do
+        DL="$(echo "${L}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
+        search -s base -b "${DL},${SUFFIX}" "(|(fripostCanAddList=${U},${SUFFIX})
+                                               (fripostCanAddList=${DU},${SUFFIX})
+                                               (fripostOwner=${U},${SUFFIX})
+                                               (fripostPostmaster=${U},${SUFFIX}))" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        search -s base -b "${L},${SUFFIX}" "(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${L}" entry/add
+    done
+done | isOK 'DENIED$' entry
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
+msg "Do not have +a or +z access to \"entry\" (unless canAddList on pending lists)"
+for U in ${USERS}; do
+    DU="$(echo "${U}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
+    for LC in ${LISTSC}; do
+        DL="$(echo "${LC}" | sed -re 's/.*,(fvd=[^,]+)$/\1/')"
+        search -s base -b "${DL},${SUFFIX}" "(|(fripostCanAddList=${U},${SUFFIX})
+                                               (fripostCanAddList=${DU},${SUFFIX})
+                                               (fripostOwner=${U},${SUFFIX})
+                                               (fripostPostmaster=${U},${SUFFIX}))" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        search -s base -b "${LC},${SUFFIX}" "(creatorsName=${U},${SUFFIX})" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        search -s base -b "${LC},${SUFFIX}" "(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+        checkACL "${U}" "${LC}" entry/add entry/delete
+    done
+done | isOK 'DENIED$' entry add
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
+
+
+
 ###########################################################################
 
 
@@ -1206,8 +1432,15 @@ for L in ${LISTS}; do
 done | isOK 'ALLOWED$'
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
+msg "Can remove the 'pending' status on list commands"
+for LC in ${LISTSC}; do
+    search -s base -b "${LC},${SUFFIXV}" "(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
+    checkACL "cn=CreateList" "${LC}" objectClass/delete:FripostPendingEntry fripostPendingToken/delete
+done | isOK 'ALLOWED$'
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
 msg "Cannot create a 'pending' satus"
-for L in ${LISTS}; do
+for L in ${LISTS} ${LISTSC}; do
     search -s base -b "${L},${SUFFIXV}" "(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
     checkACL "cn=CreateList" "${L}" objectClass/delete:FripostPendingEntry fripostPendingToken/delete
 done | isOK 'DENIED$'
@@ -1226,11 +1459,11 @@ for L in ${LISTS}; do
 done | isOK '=rsd$'
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
-msg "Have =a access on domains' children attribute"
+msg "Have =0 access on domains' children attribute"
 for D in ${DOMAINS}; do
     search -s base -b "${D},${SUFFIXV}" "(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
     checkACL "cn=CreateList" "${D}" children
-done | isOK '=a$'
+done | isOK '=0$'
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
 msg "Have =0 access on other list attributes"
@@ -1239,10 +1472,11 @@ for L in ${LISTS}; do
 done | isOK '=0$' fvl
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
-msg "Have =a access on list commands' entry attribute"
+msg "Have =rsd access on pending list commands' \"entry\" attribute"
 for LC in ${LISTSC}; do
+    search -s base -b "${LC},${SUFFIXV}" "(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)" | grep -q '^dn: ' && \
     checkACL "cn=CreateList" "${LC}" entry
-done | isOK '=a$'
+done | isOK '=rsd$' entry
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
 msg "Have =0 access on other list command attributes"
@@ -1251,6 +1485,13 @@ for LC in ${LISTSC}; do
 done | isOK '=0$' children
 [ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
 
+msg "Cannot read non pending list commands"
+for LC in ${LISTSC}; do
+    search -s base -b "${LC},${SUFFIXV}" "(objectClass=FripostPendingEntry)" | grep -q '^dn: ' || \
+    checkACL "cn=CreateList" "${LC}" entry/read entry/write
+done | isOK 'DENIED$' entry read
+[ $? -eq 0 ] || exit $?
+
 
 ###########################################################################
 
-- 
cgit v1.2.3